Electric vs Gas Cooktop vs Ceramic Cooktop
Cooktops are omnipresent in every kitchen out there. A kitchen is barely so if it accommodates a cooktop or a hob as the Brits call it. Now whatever you may call that, the sink or a microwave oven cannot cook and prepare gourmet delicacies it is a fact. Though with all the technical advancements, the latter comes close, it has not replaced the cooktop. The microwave is there for reheating the leftover food mainly. To cook is the cooktop’s job, and to reheat as well occasionally. Cooktops either come alone or paired with a baking oven. The paired cooktop is called a stove or a range. Electric vs Gas Cooktop or a ceramic cooktop makes different ideas in mind of people, which one should they get.
Cooktops come in different sizes, types, and heating methods. Whether you are remodeling the kitchen or building a new one, the choice of a suitable cooktop depends on the cost-effectiveness, the ingredients you will be blending for the recipe, and of course personal satisfaction. Before purchasing a cooktop, one has to weigh in these factors.
What are the different types of cooktops?
The types that almost everyone is familiar with, and are most common, are electric and gas. However, in recent times the third type, the induction cooktop, is becoming more popular in the United States. Each type has its own merits and demerits. Nonetheless, the ideal cooktop is the one which satisfies you and your culinary needs. The three types that are available for you to choose from are:
- Electric Cooktop
- Gas Cooktop
- Ceramic Cooktop
Electric cooktops are the most economical options of all the available cooktop types. Hence, they are most common of all in apartments and rented places, as they are more affordable than the rest and have low maintenance costs. These things make difference and we can compare these cooktops as, electric vs gas cooktop. However, an electric oven in a modern kitchen does not look bad at all. Electricity, as it is there in the name, is the source for heating. Electric Cooktops come in two forms, coil cooktop and smooth ceramic top.
Electric Coil Cooktops
An electric coil cooktop consists of a steel coil for heating the pans and pots. The heat comes from electricity, and the coil conducts it. The coil, in turn, heats the utensil.
Electric coil cooktops are a bargain when compared to smooth ceramic tops, but they are slow-going. An electric coil cooktop ought to take more time than a smooth ceramic top to boil water, and the smooth ceramic is slower than both gas and induction cooktops. The electric coil cooktop is long-lasting, even when heavy pans are placed atop, wavering the worry of any damage to the coil. The coil cooktops are an ideal choice if you are not willing to dent your wallet or moving to a rented or a temporary residence. The electric coil cooktops are affordable, durable, easy to clean, and the repairs are low-costing.
Smooth Ceramic Cooktops
Smooth ceramic tops are sleek and gleamy. They are also electric powered like the coil cooktops but cost more. The heat source is present beneath the ceramic layer. The ceramic coating provides a flat surface, even-heating and gives the bright and smooth look to the tops. These tops heat much faster than the electric coil cooktops but still fall behind gas and induction cooktops. The way this cooktop works can be explained as ceramic briquettes adopted for gas grills.
Electric cooktops, both types, are cheaper than gas and induction cooktops but are less efficient. The electricity bill incurred with electric cooktops is steeper than the cost of running gas and induction cooktops.
The gas cooktop is the choice of professionals. Whether it be the chefs at a restaurant or home-based chefs looking to take their culinary skills to a Michelin-starred eating house. It is also the cooktop of many kitchens. It is so because gas cooktops are instant heaters and the temperature of the utensil is adjustable by controlling the gas. The amount of gas running to the cooktop is visible by the intensity of the flame. The gas cooktop produces the flames which are the source of heat. The cooktops require a gas supply. Without the gas, the cooktops are pointless, and you would have to look for either an electric or an induction cooktop. Even though they are costlier than the electric, the gas cooktops do not contribute much to the electricity bill, unlike the electric cooktops. These cooktops are operable without any electric supply.
The gas cooktops are capable of heating any pan, even the heavy ones. The flames allow you to roast by placing the food directly on the flames. With the gas cooktops, be cautious while using them as there is a hazard of starting a fire. The gas cooktops can be harder to clean than electric cooktops due to the gas. Electric vs gas cooktop is really a choice of the consumer what type of cooktop she/he wants.
There is another type which utilizes the electromagnetic radiation for heating, the induction cooktop. The electric and gas cooktops are still popular, and the choice of either one is debatable. Let’s delve in to see which the better one is!
What are the advantages of the electric vs gas cooktop?
Like we said earlier, each type has its own merits and demerits, preference of the individual matters. Would you instead have an easy-to-use and safe cooktop or are you looking for a cooktop that can prepare gourmet food? What makes an electric cooktop better than a gas cooktop? Worry not! We have got the answers. Electric vs gas cooktop could depend on various conditions, depend on the following things as well.
Easier Cleaning: Cooking can be a messy job. Even boiling noodles leaves a mess on the cooktop; the sauces are even more problematic. The electric cooktops cannot avert the spills, but they are much easier to clean. All you need is a cleaner and a piece of cloth to bring back the sleek cooktop. The cleaning of the inside of electric coil cooktop is easy as well because the coil is easily removable.
Economical: An electric coil cooktop is much cheaper than a gas cooktop. The price of a low-end gas cooktops is between an electric coil cooktop and a smooth ceramic top. Either you are looking to maintain the weight of the wallet or moving to a rented apartment, an electric coil cooktop is the one for you to have.
Low-cost and Easy Repairs: The electric cooktops are low maintenance. The cost of repairs is also less than gas cooktops. If there is something wrong with the coil, it is easily replaceable with a new one, which is readily available from the market. Meanwhile, the gas cooktops are in for massive bills if there are problems with the gas supply.
Affordable Oven for Baking: If you are a baker looking to get a cooking range and planning on using the cooktop less often and the oven more, then the stove with an electric cooktop will be ideal. The electric cooktop will cut the price of the range. A gas cooking range costs more than an electric. If you are looking to bake more, then an electric cooking range will save you a hefty sum of money.
What are the disadvantages of the electric cooktop over the gas cooktop?
With all the merits stated above, an electric cooktop is far from being perfect. They have their demerits, some of which might keep you from having one. Electric vs gas cooktop, where we like electric more there could some little disadvantages too.
Slow Heating: Electric cooktops are unrushed while heating. Perhaps, it is a bit too slow. Heating on an electric cooktop is more time-consuming than other cooktops. Also, the coil cools down. The gas counterpart is effective in heating as it directs the flames towards the pan.
Uneven Distribution of Heat: The uneven heating by an electric cooktop often ruins the food. Though the food might still be palatable, the gas cooktop does a better job in uniform heating of the food. The uneven heating is one of the reasons that restaurants do not use an electric cooktop.
High Temperatures: Electric cooktops are ineffective in maintaining high temperatures. High temperatures are damaging to the coil which you would have to replace afterward.
Choice of Cookware: While using an electric cooktop, you have to be mindful of the selection of the utensil. For instance, the smooth ceramic tops are incapable of heating a cast iron pan. The shape of the cookware has to be symmetric to make contact with the surface of the coil. The case is not the same with gas cooktops, as the direct heating is adequate for any utensil.
High Running Costs: While the electric coil cooktops are cheaper than gas cooktops, they are costly when in use. The electricity bills of electric cooktops are much higher. A gas cooktop might not even need electric supply, provided that you have a lighter or a matchbox.
What are the advantages of the gas cooktop over the electric cooktop?
If you are still double minded about the choice of your cooktop, carry on reading, and hopefully, you will be able to conclude and make a decision. Similar to the electric cooktop, a gas cooktop has both advantages and disadvantages. We start with the benefits that will make you want to purchase a gas cooktop over an electric one.
Instant Heating: A gas cooktop is quick when it comes to heating, the reason why professional chefs have them in their restaurants. The quick heat increases the temperature right away, thus making the gas cooktops for cooking at high temperatures. This shows the difference between gas and electric stove cooking.
Heat Visualization: A secret to a well-cooked meal is the right amount of heat. Since the gas cooktops produce flames, a chef can visualize the amount of heat transferring to the pan. Setting the right amount of heat is crucial for a chef to serve a platter of delicious food. This point also makes a difference in different espresso and coffee machines working differently, which different styles of coffees.
Temperature Control: Temperature is controllable by adjusting the amount of gas supplied. This feature is absent in electric cooktops. The gas cooktops are effective in raising the temperature as well as lowering it to a certain level. Electric vs gas cooktop could be seen in either way. We told you in above about why electric is better, all that matters is your own condition and needs.
Even Cooking: Whatever the cookware may be, the gas cooktops transfer the heat uniformly throughout the utensil. A gas cooktop is a necessity for heating a cast iron cookware. A gas cooktop accentuates the flavors of food much better than an electric cooktop.
Low Running Costs: As long as the gas is cheaper than electricity, the gas cooktop will cost less to use than an electric cooktop. If you switch from electric to gas, you will observe a significant drop in the electricity bills.
No need for electricity: A gas cooktop is operable during a power shutdown or whenever there is no electricity. That is if you have the gas supply running. You can use your lighter or a matchstick to start cooking.
What are the disadvantages of the gas cooktop over the electric cooktop?
With all its plus points, a gas cooktop might still not be the right option for some people. This is also for all the right reasons.
Safety: With a gas cooktop, there is always a chance of fire that could burn down the house or the cooktop blowing up. An electric oven has less to no chances of either happening as compared to a gas cooktop.
Asthma/Allergies: It is possible that you or someone at your home might be allergic to the gas. People with asthma may also be concerned about the gas. It has been making difference as electric vs gas cooktop health.
Gas Supply: A gas cooktop without the gas is like a gun without bullets. Not every house has a gas supply, and the installation of a gas line is a costly procedure. If you cannot afford to do so, then an electric cooktop is a more suitable option.
Which is better, gas cooktop or electric cooktop?
Now that all the pros and cons for both cooktops have been laid out, it should be easier for you to decide which one you should get. While doing so, be sure to keep your budget in mind. Getting an electric cooktop will seem to be the right choice if you are staying on a budget. If you are a food connoisseur and an enthusiast, the gas cooktop is the one for you if you can afford it. If you are still uncertain, then you ought to check out the induction cooktops.
- 1 Electric vs Gas Cooktop vs Ceramic Cooktop
- 1.1 What are the different types of cooktops?
- 1.2 Electric Cooktop
- 1.3 Smooth Ceramic Cooktops
- 1.4 Gas Cooktops
- 1.5 What are the advantages of the electric vs gas cooktop?
- 1.6 What are the disadvantages of the electric cooktop over the gas cooktop?
- 1.7 What are the advantages of the gas cooktop over the electric cooktop?
- 1.8 What are the disadvantages of the gas cooktop over the electric cooktop?
- 1.9 Which is better, gas cooktop or electric cooktop?